You may not get what you pay for
Recently, two friends of mine consulted me on bar etiquette. They found fruitflys in their bourbons and were surprised that the bartender did nothing but shrug it off, rather than apologize, remake the drink and buy it for them. What can I say? Some bartenders are idiots.
But it reminded me of a certain practice that is apparently rampant in many bars in New York: refilling the bottles. It only happened to me at one bar I worked at, but a new bartender we had that we tried to protect from our disingenous business shrugged it off and said he'd seen it a couple times before. Now the State Liquor Authority forbids such practice and they do come in if they suspect something and test the liquor to make certain the bar isn't breaking the law, but they only thing they can really test is the alcohol level of the bottle. So there is no way to tell if the bottle is true Absolut or just plain (cheaper) Smirnoff. As long as the bar pays attention to the proof of the liquor, they will never be caught as long as employees keep their mouths shut. And even then, it's tough to prove.
One night, a guest complained that he was not getting true Cuervo Gold. He wasn't. The color was especially off. But to calm the guest, I brought the bottle over and poured the shots right at the table. That satisfied him.
You should be aware that this would possibly be the case in smaller bars or bars where the owner is cheap or just plain greedy, two instances that would be impossible to know. My owner was just plain greedy. He was also the same guy of the sexist, racist persuasion that I mentioned in an earlier post. When you are in a bar, pay attention to the bottles on the back wall. If they all have pourers in them, rather than closed and sealed, it is possible they refill the bottles. This is not always the case as bartenders might prepare for a busy night by setting up some bottles as ready to pour. But it's something to look for anyway.
But it reminded me of a certain practice that is apparently rampant in many bars in New York: refilling the bottles. It only happened to me at one bar I worked at, but a new bartender we had that we tried to protect from our disingenous business shrugged it off and said he'd seen it a couple times before. Now the State Liquor Authority forbids such practice and they do come in if they suspect something and test the liquor to make certain the bar isn't breaking the law, but they only thing they can really test is the alcohol level of the bottle. So there is no way to tell if the bottle is true Absolut or just plain (cheaper) Smirnoff. As long as the bar pays attention to the proof of the liquor, they will never be caught as long as employees keep their mouths shut. And even then, it's tough to prove.
One night, a guest complained that he was not getting true Cuervo Gold. He wasn't. The color was especially off. But to calm the guest, I brought the bottle over and poured the shots right at the table. That satisfied him.
You should be aware that this would possibly be the case in smaller bars or bars where the owner is cheap or just plain greedy, two instances that would be impossible to know. My owner was just plain greedy. He was also the same guy of the sexist, racist persuasion that I mentioned in an earlier post. When you are in a bar, pay attention to the bottles on the back wall. If they all have pourers in them, rather than closed and sealed, it is possible they refill the bottles. This is not always the case as bartenders might prepare for a busy night by setting up some bottles as ready to pour. But it's something to look for anyway.

